We welcome Dan Cox, a Los Angeles–based entrepreneur and the visionary founder of the wellness brands Wealthy and Metcon. From his early days behind the retail counter to building and scaling multi-seven-figure CPG brands, Dan has mastered the transition from hands-on customer service to national distribution on major platforms like Amazon and GNC.
In this powerful conversation, Seb and Dan dive deep into the grit required to build a modern wellness empire without outside funding. They explore the “unsexy” side of the CPG industry, from the high stakes of inventory management to the logistical nightmare of single-origin sourcing, and why the “better for you” category is often just a marketing trap. They also tackle the toxicity of chasing trends, the reality of “learning by screwing up,” and why true brand longevity depends on prioritizing customer trust over short-term Meta-ad wins. This episode is a masterclass on the discipline of scaling a business while staying anchored to a personal ethos in a flavor-first world.
LISTEN to this pod right here by clicking play or choose your favorite listening platform below. You can also WATCH the video podcast below that! Check out the show notes at the bottom to get more details about the contents of this episode. Enjoy!
Show notes as a general guide below. Somewhat in order and not written in perfect grammar because we want you to actually listen to the show!
Topics Discussed
- Retail Roots
- The “Ugly” Side of CPG
- The “Better for a Few” Myth
- Supplement Trust & FDA
- Flavor is King
- D2C vs. Retail Reality
- Bootstrapping & Ingredient Ethos
- The 80/20 Founder Discipline
- Learning Through Failure
- The Anti-Mentorship Stance
Connect with Dan on Instagram
Connect with Wellthy here
Connect with MetCon here
Connect with Sebastian on Instagram
SebastianNaum.com
Below is a transcript of the video podcast created by Seb’s Robot buddy, Zekton. He tends to make mistakes so please forgive him if you find errors or some funky sounding sentences. For the real deal, watch the video or click on your favorite audio Podcast platform above! Enjoy!
(00:00) Sebastian: Welcome everyone, I’d like to welcome Dan Cox, the founder of Wealthy and Metcon. Let’s give him a hand.
(00:07) Dan: Thank you guys for having me, Seb.
(00:10) Sebastian: My name is Sebastian Nam Leon. If you don’t know me, I have a podcast called Aware with Seb, so this is a live recording of the podcast. So later on, if you guys want to check it out, you’ll get to check it out there. And Dan, I want to start with a quick smash or pass, alright? I’m going to go rapid fire. Here we go.
(00:26) Dan: Wait, before we started this he asked me is anything off limits? I didn’t think smash or pass was going to be the first question, Seb.
(00:32) Sebastian: Exactly. You said nothing. So, taking pre-workout before a podcast interview?
(00:37) Dan: Uh, yeah. Smash.
(00:38) Sebastian: Launching a product with only a white label formula?
(00:41) Dan: Pass.
(00:42) Sebastian: Launching D2C without a plan for retail?
(00:45) Dan: Uh, smash.
(00:47) Sebastian: Gym selfies and ice baths as founder marketing strategy?
(00:51) Dan: Smash.
(00:52) Sebastian: Celebrity-backed wellness brands?
(00:54) Dan: Smash.
(00:55) Sebastian: Private equity entering the supplement space?
(00:57) Dan: Smash.
(00:59) Sebastian: People that read supplement labels like a wine connoisseur?
(01:03) Dan: Yeah, smash.
(01:05) Sebastian: And engaging your audience to decide on new product drops?
(01:09) Dan: Uh, smash.
(01:10) Sebastian: Awesome. Thank you. We got a very quiet audience today. You guys can loosen up, you know, we’re just hanging out, talking about CPG and modern wellness. Well, Dan, I’m stoked to have you here. Before you started scaling CPG brands nationally, you were behind the counter selling wellness products. What were some of those early on conversations that—what did you learn from some of those early on conversations about what people wanted with wellness brands?
(01:38) Dan: Yeah, for sure. So, so a little bit of background. I have a history in the beverage industry—healthy beverage—and then got recruited into wine, and really missed kind of health and wellness and more that side of the business. I had a friend who was opening up nutrition stores and kind of picked his brain on it, liked the business model, no experience in retail, decided to open up my first brick-and-mortar nutrition store. Very similar to like what a GNC would be, a little bit more hands-on. We would do body fat analysis scans, we would look at people’s diets. It wasn’t like a grab-and-go shop of walk in, grab your protein, and walk out. Very much hands-on. And one of the biggest things we noticed, probably about 70% of our clients were weight loss clients coming in looking for, you know, looking to achieve weight loss goals. And the hand-to-hand combat that happens when you’re working with consumers, it’s something I’ve like never taken for granted because in this world of like D2C and everyone could put up a Shopify, you’re very disconnected from the consumer. Yes, you can do surveys, yes, you can get emails, you know, you can do customer service on phone calls, but a one-on-one reaction with customers, direct feedback, coming back month after month, you really get to see what’s working, what’s not, and then just the mentality of customers and where they’re at, you know, the kind of psychology of like of goals—whether it’s building lean muscle, losing body fat, whatever it is—I got to experience that first-hand, which is unique in today’s day and age, I think.
(03:22) Sebastian: Yeah, and it’s also unique because that was a while back and people would go specifically to these types of stores. And now I feel like everybody’s got wellness goals just because of the stuff they consume on social media, the news, and all that stuff. So there’s a much more educated audience now.
(03:40) Dan: I think it’s—I think the kind of wellness category has just broadened from what used to be the kind of gym category, right? Of like it was very simple. You either wanted to build lean muscle or lose body fat. That was—that was the wellness category a decade ago, or a little bit more than that. And now it’s like I want to optimize gut health, I want to optimize my brain capacity and like neuroplasticity, and I want to, you know, I want to clear out heavy metals out of my system. There’s all these kind of micro things that are happening that have been going on that has really kind of transformed the wellness category from the days of like either give me my protein or give me my weight loss product.
(04:24) Sebastian: Yeah, yeah. Just out of curiosity here, with a raise of hands, who here has a CPG or wellness product? You have one. And then how many of you are looking to launch one or scale one or work for one? Okay. Okay, so now the majority of the room. Okay, good. In terms of when you were early on and you were having these conversations, was there a single moment you remember, “Okay, I want—I have to have my own product, my own company”?
(04:54) Dan: Uh, it was kind of a compounding thing. You know, we had—we had very strict buying standards, so similar to like a Whole Foods, right? We would vet out all our brands that we brought into the store. And even within that, we started finding a lot of one, voids in the market, but two, you know, we built up—we grew from one store to two stores, three stores, eventually five stores. We were fielding a lot of customers. And some of the questions that started coming in were different than what’s on the brand label, right? So like customers come in and be like, “Hey, where’s this protein coming from? What’s the extraction method on this collagen?” because they read an article that said something and they wanted to know. We would reach out to the brands and the brands would have no idea. You know, one time I remember calling a protein manufacturer and asking, “Hey, where’s your—like where’s your dairy coming from?” And they’re like, “What’s the lot number?” And I’m like, “Oh, this is a problem.” So basically every lot is coming from a different raw material supplier. And that was kind of like the aha moment of okay, we’re the front line of defense for our customers. We’re now selling products that we can’t even tell our customers. We have to look at a lot number to reference a sheet to see where that protein is coming from. Like this is a major problem. So I started building relationships with raw material suppliers, kind of diving into the business, and then manufacturers. And that’s when I realized like the supplement business, it’s no different than the beverage business, it’s no different than the food business, bars, whatever it is. Everyone’s working with co-mans, so co-manufacturers. So every brand is reaching out to these co-manufacturers that produce products for hundreds of brands. Those co-mans know that you’re sourcing from other co-mans. So you’re literally as a brand, if you start up, you’re like, “I’m going to start a protein company. I’m going to reach out to say five co-mans.” You now reach out to them. They know they’re competing for you mostly on price because you have no idea how they are to work together. So that co-man is incentivized to source the cheapest raw materials they can find to then quote you the cheapest price to gain the business. And then as the product continues to grow, they’ll continue to source—if you don’t say—they’ll continue to source the lowest raw material products they can find again to keep their margins high and to keep your prices low to keep your business. And that was kind of the aha moment of we can’t let manufacturers do that. We’re going to create our own raw material supply, and that was one of our big pillars. We source all our own raw materials. We have single origin ingredients, so every product has the same raw material supplier no matter how many ingredients there are. And that was kind of our initial point of differentiation of why I wanted to start a brand.
(07:31) Sebastian: Yeah, and so that’s why you wanted to start it. That’s how you started it. And Dan, this is part of the reason why this category is one of the most trust-sensitive categories in terms of CPG, supplements, and things like that. How—how do you build trust, but also how do we as consumers, how can we trust? Like who can we trust? How do you really fact-check?
(07:54) Dan: It’s—obviously there’s a ton of ways. This is like a very loaded question, right? I would say the supplement industry in general is actually by nature a very trustworthy industry. And the reason being is the standards that are put in place. Everyone says, “Well, the supplements aren’t regulated by the FDA.” Technically they’re not, but the manufacturers are regulated by the FDA. So manufacturers have to have an FDA certification, they have to have a GMP certification, or else no one’s going to work with them. NSF is new, Informed-Choice, Informed-Sport. So the industry as a whole, I would say is genuinely trustworthy. It didn’t always use to be. There was a lot of products, you know, that would come in the market that weren’t produced by FDA-backed manufacturers, right? That’s all changed. Anything that is on shelves in stores, anything that is on Amazon right now has to be produced by an FDA-regulated facility. And if not, it’s going to be off platform very shortly. So in general, trustworthy. So that’s like a narrative that I think a lot of people have is like you can’t supplements are shady, you can’t trust them. It is—it is a very trustworthy, you know, as a macro kind of category. From a micro standpoint, we live in a bubble here in LA. The coasts are—are different in kind of the nuances of what we care about, the information we look at. We’re a little bit more intense about that. So, you know, from a buying practice standpoint as like a general rule, if a founder is in front of the brand, they’re going to have to answer questions. And that is a generally a trustworthy kind of thing, I think. Brands that put out their certificate of analysis, brands that talk about their manufacturing practices. You know, brands that are kind of more open and you see behind the curtains, I think creates more trust with a customer. And again, that trust is really from a small percentage of customers that actually care. The majority of customers just want to know: does it taste good? Am I going to get results from it? Those are kind of the two main ones.
(10:04) Sebastian: Yeah, and when it comes to a lot of brands are claiming third-party testing. Is it something that, you know, consumers just get to go and ask that, okay, well what is this third-party testing really about? Who’s actually doing it? Because a lot of times the third-party testing seems like it’s also funded by the company. Like there’s this whole thing.
(10:23) Dan: Yeah, so so almost every FDA-regulated facility does third-party testing. So when brands say—it’s almost like saying “our product is science-backed.” It’s like, “Hmm.” It’s like calling wine “reserved.” Like everything is science-backed, every ingredient has science, has PubMed studies on it. So, you know, the third-party testing is kind of becoming that too. It is a standard practice in the industry. The extent of the third-party testing is up to the brand. So manufacturers do have to send out product. They will send out a batch. It will be tested in typically the testing facility will test for like, depending on the number of ingredients, they’ll test for like one or two ingredients for efficacy. They’ll test for heavy metals, they’ll test for pathogens. And so that typically comes back and then the product is released. If like, for example, like Amazon in a lot of like different categories like weight loss, sport nutrition, they will request further third-party testing. So they’ll say, “Okay, we got your certificate of analysis, we saw one test was done, we want you to test four other ingredients.” So there’s constantly testing going on, but the third-party testing thing is pretty standard practice now. Brands are using it as like an uplift, like we’re better than everyone else when they’re just calling it out.
(11:46) Sebastian: Now on Amazon, it still seems to me that there’s a lot of just sort of private label slap on—slap a sticker on type of brand. Perhaps an offshore thing, so maybe it doesn’t—does it still have to pass third-party tests just to be sold in the US even if it’s from overseas?
(12:05) Dan: Yeah, so—so general vitamin categories aren’t as much scrutinized. So like say if there’s just a Vitamin D on the market, Amazon isn’t as concerned with that. When you start making claims like weight loss, like energy, pre-workouts for example, things like that, Amazon has a little—they kind of have a little bit higher standard of “we want to make sure these are regulated.” So they will require brands once a year to submit testing, send in, and sometimes even request further testing. So it depends on the category of product in that space.
(12:41) Sebastian: Gotcha, gotcha. Dan, well we’re going to talk a little bit about branding and and scaling and marketing and all those things, but before we kind of get into that, people do see branding and packaging and Instagram and it all looks really sexy on the outside. But the reality is that we’re looking at inventory and margins and supply chains and logistics. So what does your day-to-day look like in terms of of the hustle of the day-to-day as a CPG founder?
(13:14) Dan: Managing all the ugly stuff.
(13:16) Sebastian: Yeah. Putting out a fire.
(13:17) Dan: Yeah, so—so yeah, putting out fires. I mean it’s constant between, you know, hitting PO deadlines for retailers, you know, yeah, managing inventory levels, sourcing issues. Again, we source single origin only, so if we have a product with nine ingredients and one of our ingredient suppliers is out of stock, we got an issue. We’re not going to—we’re not going to go against our ethos, we’re not going to change. So just managing expectations, managing retail buyer expectations, pushing marketing, you know, looking at different programming that’s going on in the different chains we’re in. It’s a constant wheel of everything and a lot of the non-sexy that you don’t see.
(14:04) Sebastian: Yeah, absolutely. You said “we’re not going to go against our ethos” in terms of if you’re looking at—we got nine ingredients and they’re all single ingredients, you don’t have it, you’re basically going to be out of stock, which obviously hurts you specifically—especially if you’re on Amazon, you’re out of stock on something, Amazon hates you for that, right? They kind of like bump you down on that. How do you go about making those decisions in terms of how it trickles down from your personal ethos into your teams?
(14:35) Dan: I mean it’s just managing—it’s just trying to get ahead of it, trying to solve problems before they happen, right? So managing inventory, projecting, you know, getting your projections right on on certain products and SKUs, and just making sure that you minimize those issues as much because that’s not an issue if you have stock, right? So just making sure that’s not a—limiting the opportunity for that to be a problem.
(15:01) Sebastian: Yeah, yeah. What’s the most expensive mistake you’ve ever made?
(15:06) Dan: Oh, that’s a good question. All these are always like learnings too, right? I would say one thing we thought we had a—we had a collagen—one of our best-selling products is a single origin collagen. Our customers were requesting that they wanted flavored collagen. So we set out to go against the grain, go against natural—you know, Vital Proteins, everyone was producing chocolate flavored, vanilla flavored. And we were like what if we do whole foods as the flavor? So we led this kind of single origin putting it, you know, kind of front and center on our sleeve. We’re working directly with the farms to source organic regeneratively farmed cacao out of Ecuador. We’re sourcing a Peruvian blue-green algae that’s wild harvested at a lake that is literally away from any source of pollution. We’re sourcing the most expensive Japanese Matcha we could find that was ceremonial grade and we used that to flavor the collagen. I—I thought it was a good idea. It was a very expensive undertaking, and the customer at the end of the day wants great flavors. And so that was a thing where we we spent a lot of time on that product. So it wasn’t just like oh, the product cost, you know, it sold, it was fine, just didn’t move that quick, but the amount of time and effort we put into it, I mean it was a it was a year project that didn’t pan out the way we thought it was going to.
(16:35) Sebastian: Something I’ve learned from you from our conversations in the past is that people keep coming back for flavor, actually, more so than the effect or the feeling of a product. That was kind of shocking to me.
(16:49) Dan: I mean you can see it in the gummy space, you can see it in the green space, you can see it in protein. Like I know we’re all in this place of like, you know, we like natural flavors are bad and we want, you know, it like the majority of the country doesn’t care. And I go back to—there was a—are anyone familiar with BodyArmor, the beverage company? How many through a show of hands? Now out of those show of hands, how many people have drank BodyArmor? Not a single one. BodyArmor was the biggest single beverage sale in the history of the world. And not a single person I knew in my circle, CPG friends, had ever drank it. Not only that, they don’t shop at a store that carries it. And it was a single beverage sale, biggest single beverage sale in history. And so that just shows you again, I always talk—and I know we get beat up about being in a bubble—but we definitely are in a bubble that is not the rest of the country. And the rest of the country, flavor is king. So you look at like the protein category, the proteins that drive the business are completely artificial flavored, completely artificially sweetened, and they are the majority of the business.
(18:13) Sebastian: Yeah, we were talking about it just yesterday. I was telling Dan that Expo West I tried a ton of the like Liquid IV flavors—the sugar-free Liquid IV flavors, even though they’re jammed with sucralose and all kinds of other stuff. And I was telling you that four out of five I tried I thought were just so like disgusting. And I’m like how could they have gone through all these flavors? Like they have so much marketing budget and testing budget and research budget. I’m sure they tested these flavors. And you basically said the same thing, you’re like:
(18:43) Dan: They tested against people with palettes that drink Coke and Sprite, right? Because that’s the majority of the customer base.
(18:49) Sebastian: That’s wild. So when online exploded in 2020 through 2022, I think a lot of people assumed that you could just go to town on direct-to-consumer and that’s how you can grow and that’s how you can scale. But what’s the reality that you’ve learned of scaling beyond direct-to-consumer? If you want, you could also tell us how you—how you grew initially, but how that’s gone into the into the retail space.
(19:18) Dan: Yeah, I mean that period, I mean we all know that period, like you couldn’t buy stuff anywhere. It was very expensive, so you buy online and a lot of companies blew up. And talking about Expo West, it’s very interesting to see like in 2022, the brands that were at Expo West because they were kind of on this uplift from COVID, a number of them were not there in 23. And so there was kind of this, oh this will be the way it is forever, and it definitely the pendulum swung back from direct-to-consumer back into retail. And retail is now has this power. So I’ve seen a couple of these cycles and I think because we’ve grown so slow, we haven’t—we haven’t raised money, and we started out in my stores. I built a brand for my five retail stores that then started growing outside. We’ve kind of weathered as well as adapted to the moving tide, and have gone—you know, we went hard into Amazon and direct-to-consumer. Now we’re going, you know, very much more back into where we were born, which is retail.
(20:25) Sebastian: And so it’s got to be pretty important then to be shifting and adapting with the waves of how people are consuming product.
(20:31) Dan: For sure. And there’s ways to stay on all fronts. It’s just very expensive, right? If—you know, like when Meta ads got very expensive, you saw a lot of companies losing money because they kept driving onto that channel. And now it’s coming back and there’s just ebbs and flows in the market. So there’s ways to stay on it, it’s just expensive.
(20:53) Sebastian: Yeah, absolutely. What is the biggest shift or challenge when a brand is going from direct-to-consumer into the retail space?
(21:02) Dan: Oh, there’s—there’s so many. I mean the—a package on, you know, a PDF image on your website is very different than what that looks like on the shelf. Buyers know it, consumers know it. And so there’s a lot of learning like what works direct-to-consumer doesn’t always translate directly to retail. If the brand is big enough and you built it out, yes, there is—there’s obviously like exceptions to that rule. But to grab customers, you know, a lot of brands go into retail to, you know, obviously they want to acquire new customers. You’re not going into retail to be like, oh I want to cut my margin and send a bunch of product to stores, right? So you’re trying to bring new customers to that brand and and that presence on the shelf is very important. And so yeah, not everything translates from a JPEG to what’s on the shelf. And then, you know, from price points, like price—you know, people looking on Amazon have very different kind of price dynamics than people that don’t know your website and aren’t going to trust a random website to sign up for a subscription versus someone who’s shopping and they’re like, “Hey, I’ve got everything I need. Do I have another 20 bucks to try this product out?” So there’s like different psychological dynamics too. So it’s a loaded question.
(22:25) Sebastian: What would you say are kind of the biggest takeaways in terms of the psychological dynamics of pricing on Amazon versus retail?
(22:34) Dan: We—I’ll give you my take on it because I came from retail. I’m very conscious of retail and how hard it is from more the small side. So, you know, we always made sure that we kept our our Amazon and our website at a higher frontline retail at our base, you know, we didn’t sell everywhere. We didn’t want a bunch of online retailers dropping their pants and cutting the price. And the idea behind that was a customer goes into a store, they’re smart enough, they’re going to look on their phone and Google it. And when they see the retailer has the product for five dollars less than what they can get it on Amazon, that’s going to drive the purchase more than if they’re like, “Oh wait, I can save a couple bucks, it’ll be here tomorrow.” Like done. I’m just
(23:23) Sebastian: And you want to drive that retail sale more so even though you’re likely making less money on retail because you’re selling at wholesale.
(23:31) Dan: Because it’s—think of it as customer acquisition, right? I wouldn’t otherwise have an opportunity for that customer, but they happen to be walking through that store, seeing the product, and now I get them. I’m not paying for advertising to get them. They’re literally I’m basically siphoning off the attention from that retailer.
(23:51) Sebastian: Got it. So maybe you’re making less on it because of your wholesale pricing, but your cost per acquisition is also going to be less because you weren’t running ads to get them. And then the potential lifetime value of somebody—do you think that there’s a lifetime value potentially higher on somebody on retail because they like to get used to going to a certain aisle and then they get the thing versus them buying online all the time?
(24:14) Dan: I think it’s—this is very like nuanced in the customer, right? In the customer dynamic. But yes, there are customers that are that, you know, one thing I learned in the alcohol space is, you know, in liquor stores you always see those little bottles, right? The actual cost per serving on that is extremely high. But the kind of lowest income people will buy those. And the reason is the habitual nature of going to the store, the practice, the social aspect of not buying a bigger bottle for for economy. And a lot of that that’s not like apples to apples, but it translates into retail of people that I go to Target every Saturday and it’s kind of just their practice and they pick up what they need. There is a lot of that, you know, but there is also the idea of you want to have less resistance for the customer. So if you are in retail, they can buy it there. If you are on Amazon, they could buy it there. They could also subscribe to your site and save some money. So that to me is the bigger ticket of like okay, we are we are restricting the amount of friction for our customers so wherever they’re at, they can find our products when it’s most convenient for them.
(25:24) Sebastian: Got it. Awesome. What do you think carried—has carried over the most from your experience with alcohol all the way to wellness?
(25:35) Dan: The categories—I will say wine and supplements are very similar.
(25:39) Sebastian: Really?
(25:40) Dan: For for one particular reason. Everyone wants a recommendation. So very few times you walk down the wine aisle, you know, are you looking at the bottle label or are you like, “Oh my friend told me about this” or “I heard this one was good.” Supplements are very similar. They share that kind of similar similarity of like, “Oh my friend’s taking this. I saw so-and-so post this.” More than any other category, I feel like those two are—and maybe because I’m in it and I see the similarities more—but the the customer wanting a friend’s recommendation or someone else to sign off on it. And they’re both ingestible, so.
(26:19) Sebastian: That’s funny. Wine and wellness. Dan, so I have a growth marketing agency that I’ve had for 10 years now. And I’ve worked with tons of CPG and wellness brands and seen a lot of shifts and changes over the years in marketing. And I got to be sort of on the forefront when Facebook ads were launching, which ages me a little bit, but basically I took a 15K ad spend early on and it turned into $330,000 in sales, so that’s a pretty massive ROAS at the time and that’s shifted and changed significantly. So before I do want to talk a little bit about TikTok Shop and TikTok affiliate and live selling because that’s kind of all the rage right now in marketing. But before that, what was—what worked for you early on in terms of the the Meta space or the influencer space? What worked and what didn’t?
(27:14) Dan: Influencers did. Meta we never kind of found our footing.
(27:20) Sebastian: What year was it by the way? Just for context.
(27:22) Dan: I mean COVID time. So basically we shifted from our retail stores to selling the brand primarily Amazon and D2C around that like 2000 2001—excuse me 2020.
(27:38) Sebastian: You did the opposite of what a lot of people have to do now, which is launching D2C and then shifting into retail.
(27:44) Dan: Correct. So we we started playing around. We never really found our footing in Meta and one of the reasons was the majority of our products and our top sellers are metabolism products. So Meta has a very strong kind of allergy against things that help metabolism. So I have a beef with Meta about that and TikTok. They have no problem selling products that will, you know, cause unhealthy gut, diabetes, different diseases, but you can’t sell products that will help people get healthy. So—so we always had a challenge with Meta and TikTok because of that. Our biggest growth method was trial, and one of the partners we found early that really helped us—anyone know FabFitFun? Great membership base, ability to reach a number of customers nationwide, very extremely low margin, but trial. And we used that—
(28:44) Sebastian: Can you expand on what the definition of trial is?
(28:46) Dan: Yeah, so literally a customer being able to try a product for an entry-level price, so cheaper than what they would find in retail because they have a membership. That allowed us not to bastardize our price, and we got to have a lot of trial early from customers that probably had no idea about the brand, but it was a decent price so they were like, “Oh you know what, it’s worth a try.” That is what grew and probably worked best for us.
(29:14) Sebastian: And you found different trial distribution companies and things like that?
(29:19) Dan: Mom and pop retailers were another one. You know, when we’re on a shelf—let’s let’s—we’re in GNC. We’re on—we have a lot of competition in that store. If we sell to a mom and pop, we get them fired up on the product. We are maybe one of two in the category, and if they like our product, if customers are getting more benefits from our product than the other one they have, that retailer is going to continue to push our product hard. So creating those kind of like just mini sales people across the country.
(29:51) Sebastian: Yeah. What about product seeding early on? How hard do you go on product seeding in terms of free product seeding?
(29:58) Sebastian: On the trial side, are you at least covering costs when it comes to that?
(30:02) Dan: Depends on on where, right?
(30:04) Sebastian: Okay, so not always.
(30:05) Dan: But yeah, like a lot of times you are.
(30:07) Sebastian: Got it. So then in terms of product seeding where you’re not covering costs, how does how does that go?
(30:13) Dan: It’s good, man. And it was better obviously when there wasn’t as much of it on social media. And now anything anyone sees on social media, they assume it’s a brand deal. And so there’s a little bit more—you don’t get the same response you used to get in 2020, 2021 on seeding, but it’s still good. And I almost think it’s think of an influencer trying the product, it’s almost better for their small circle of friends when they’re like, “Well I know you got gifted that product, but what do you really think about it?” And then all of a sudden oh, the product’s really good. So their small circle starts talking about it. To me that’s like that’s how it’s done now. Like yes, brand awareness is great, but everyone has this like this kind of filter up that as soon as you see a product on social media, you assume it’s paid, especially from someone with a decent following.
(31:07) Sebastian: Yeah, and that’s the thing with influencer marketing that’s shifted significantly in the marketing world. You just don’t trust influencers anymore.
(31:16) Dan: Even when even when it did work, there’s diminishing returns, right? So every influencer has a portion of their audience that is die-hard, they will do whatever this person does and says and they’ll buy everything they talk about. That—that is a small percentage of their following. That percentage buys the first time they see it. The next time, maybe a smaller percentage of that, and the next time a smaller percentage, so it’s just you literally once you siphon off an influencer, it’s not like a super long-term strategy unless someone is actively in the space, actively gaining new followers, you know, and on like a massive growth trajectory, I think the the influencer kind of paid influencer acquisition is it’s constantly diminishing returns.
(32:05) Sebastian: Yeah, what we’ve seen is at least if they are hyper-niche or extremely just they have an expertise in something very specific, let’s say it is gut health and they’re very much a gut health influencer, then that tends to work better as opposed to if they just have an influence because they have a big audience. And the other side of that though, Dan, and I’m curious about this is on the micro-influencer side, we’ve seen that work really well because now we’re talking about everydayers what we call it in marketing it’s like everyday people with a very small following, they’re more trustworthy because they’re not typically getting paid to post stuff so now it’s like their friends and family that are seeing it, right?
(32:47) Dan: Not only that, but if the content’s good, it’s going to get exposed to other people, right? So yeah, I think there’s definitely a good cost-to-benefit ratio of kind of the micro-influencer seeding. And again, their small group of friends is really what’s it’s going to impact.
(33:04) Sebastian: Yeah, exactly. Which is just similar to the “hey, my friend recommended this” and now you see it on the shelf. Everyone online is talking about TikTok affiliate and TikTok Shop and live selling. Any—just out of curiosity, anyone here doing that right now as a marketing strategy for the brand that you work for, the brand that you have? TikTok Shop or TikTok affiliates? Okay, just a few. Okay. So when it comes to that, what I’ve seen is that you sort of need this this wow factor within like the first two or three seconds to get people’s attention for for affiliates to actually sell products on TikTok and things like that, while a lot of CPG or wellness products don’t necessarily have that major wow factor. So at that point it’s we recommend it as a big awareness play. “Hey, go massify your awareness, get millions of views so that it can help your retail push.” What have you—what have you experienced with TikTok Shop specifically and affiliates?
(34:04) Dan: A lot of spinning wheels, a lot of really bad content. You know, the kind of initial and I’ve talked to a lot of brands about this, the initial influx of your affiliates is very subpar to say the least from a creator standpoint. And even the biggest brands, they’re really only it’s the top 1% of their affiliates that are actually moving the needle, but to find that 1%, you gotta send out thousands and thousands of units. And so it is a game of it’s a timing game, it’s a it’s a constant pressure on of just honestly throwing as much shit against the wall as you can, knowing that you’re going to get back a lot of subpar content in order to find that that 1% that can convert for you.
(34:57) Sebastian: That’s for conversions.
(34:58) Dan: For conversions. Yeah. And brand awareness is brand awareness, but again, like some of this content, it’s not reaching anybody. Like it’s so bad, it’s just not reaching anybody. So it still is that you know kind of top percent of people. And then on top of that, brands are then having to whitelist those. So any content that actually works from an affiliate standpoint, they’re then putting money to to push it out more. And what we’ve seen is the amount of money being put towards that content is directly impacting to the conversions of it, and it’s usually exceeding what the organic conversion was of that original piece of content.
(35:45) Sebastian: So, and do you see a positivity on—a positive side of it in terms of if you’re just trying to massify awareness on a product that you’re launching or trying to get some retail velocity and and get it off the get it off the shelves?
(35:59) Dan: Correct. Retail impact is—is a real thing. We have heard that from retailers like, “Oh this brand’s popping off on TikTok so we brought it in” or “This brand’s popping off on TikTok we’ve seen sales increase,” right? So that is a real part of it. Again, we struggle with it because our top sellers are not we’re not able to sell on TikTok Shop. But for a lot of brands
(36:22) Sebastian: Because of the whole—
(36:24) Dan: Because of the—there is just a—there is a policy on Meta and on TikTok against metabolism products. So you can’t say, yeah. And brands will get on there and then they’ll get shut down. So I know a handful that had really hockey stick growth on TikTok Shop and then one day shut off and they can’t get back on.
(36:47) Sebastian: Wild.
(36:48) Sebastian: Dan, you are scaling not just one, but two brands: Wealthy and Metcon. And you’re also a father of a one-year-old and we assume you have some friends. So how do you structure this hustle in your life without burning out, man?
(37:07) Dan: It’s crazy. I I will say having parents
(37:12) Sebastian: Not as many parents.
(37:13) Dan: Not as many parents. There’s something that happens when you become a parent. I can’t explain it, I’ve talked to a lot of entrepreneurs that do. You get laser focused. Um, your time becomes that much more valuable. You think your time’s valuable now, and then when you have a kid that literally you like leave for a second and you’re like, “Oh my god, like all I want to do is spend time with this kid.” Your time becomes much more valuable, at least from my standpoint. So condensing the day, removing waste, and then honestly like focusing on focusing on the most impactful things. Like that is that is what’s kind of I think helped me over the last year. I—I don’t know if what I’m doing is right. Actually I’ll tell you this: I know what I’m doing is wrong because if you talk to any expert, they’re going to say focus on one thing, do it right, head down. I think I’d go crazy. And I kind of need like some other little things to to pinch at. And that’s just for me. I started so Wealthy is our primary brand, leads the majority of the business. We started Wealthy and Metcon at the same time. Metcon is much more sport nutrition focused. And again, think about my retail stores: we had weight loss customers and we had sport nutrition customers. I created a brand for each of those in the stores. We’ve continued to grow those. Wealthy drives the majority of the business, has the most kind of success. Metcon just still kind of runs and it’s almost like the sick thing that I want to hold on to it because I know it has potential, but I can’t put any more time into it than what I have available and because Wealthy has driven so much of that business. And again, now that I have a kid, and then randomly after COVID my wife’s family farm almost went out of business so we helped save it and now seasonally on the weekends we help them and so there’s a lot going on. And I probably do and will continue to like focus down, but yeah, it’s it’s a lot.
(39:31) Sebastian: It’s a lot. You said removing the waste in order to be laser focused. How what is there a trick for you to figure out what’s impactful, not impactful, like to delegate more?
(39:46) Dan: I think I know—I think delegate more, I think doubling down on what’s working, doubling down on what you think can work. I—this is it’s like there’s nothing new here, but I started reading this book, I think it’s called like 2x is harder than 10x. And they just basically like say a lot of the kind of tried and true things that are always out there. And really it’s 20% of your efforts affect 80% of the business, right? So doubling down harder on those those efforts that actually impact because a lot of that 80% that you’re doing is task oriented, there’s not going to be heavy consequences if you don’t have it on time, right? There’s like a lot of these things that don’t make sense. So it’s trying to identify what is actually impacting the business, where is my time most useful, and then doubling down on those those elements.
(40:40) Sebastian: 20% of what you do affects 80% of your business.
(40:44) Dan: And the other 80% of the time you spend only affects 20% is kind of the theory and I mean it’s tried and true, right? It’s it’s across everything.
(40:53) Sebastian: I love that. That’s a big takeaway. And that probably goes it goes way beyond CPG, wellness, or anything. Probably goes along most things that we do in life.
(41:03) Dan: 100%.
(41:04) Sebastian: Yeah, exactly. I love it. I’ll ask you a couple more questions and then I’m going to open it up to the audience to ask a couple of questions. Dan, so outside of your family and personal support, what are the two key positions in your business? Like the two key the people positions in the business that basically help you keep it all together?
(41:31) Dan: I would say my manufacturer, number one.
(41:34) Sebastian: So in the so your manufacturer and then is there a your contact at the manufacturer?
(41:40) Dan: Yeah, multiple, but yeah.
(41:42) Sebastian: Okay, multiple. Got it. And that’s for obviously like ingredient sourcing, production timelines, payment terms, all that stuff.
(41:52) Sebastian: How do they help with payment terms?
(41:54) Dan: So the bigger you build the business, the more trust you build, the more kind of just loyalty credit you build up. And so that that helps out a lot, right? When you when you need it, they’ve been there.
(42:07) Sebastian: And that’s because of big, let’s say Target comes into play, they want a big order, now all of a sudden you got to put up like 400 grand worth of a manufacture. Okay, got it. And then they’re like oh we’ll give you terms and then wait for Target to pay you and then we can pay us.
(42:21) Dan: Yep. I would say the other one is our designer. And the reason is the attention we’ve gotten on the brand. We’ve had the brand—so we focus on on gut health and weight loss. So metabolism support and gut health are two primary categories. You know, we do unique things in the ingredient space, but the majority of of kind of attention we’ve gotten on the brand has really been from our design. Like the number of people that come up and say “your packaging is like that’s what drew us in” from a customer standpoint and from a buyer standpoint. The other unique thing we made a crazy decision to go against the industry: we were one of the first companies to package capsules in gusseted bags. And that was a that was a—it wasn’t the most expensive thing, like but it was definitely a risk. Going against the industry one, you know, from a retail standpoint, a pill bottle next to a bag that’s twice the size, now you’re taking up two spaces, right? So it was a risk for the retailer. It was a risk from a manufacturing standpoint. There was no automated manufacturing machine that could run capsules through a pill—through a gusseted bag. And so working with my designer, getting feedback, outside, you know, influence on what’s going on in the rest of the category, what’s not being done, how—like to me that was like I mean that was
(43:56) Sebastian: This isn’t just your typical graphic designer. This is a designer who’s really thinking about the entire design of the product and the packaging and the psychology behind how it all interacts.
(44:07) Dan: Correct.
(44:09) Sebastian: That’s great. That’s good to know. Yeah. Dan, so this is the Aware with Seb podcast, so I’m going to ask our last question, which is: what should people be aware of today? But it’s going to be a two-parter. So what should consumers be most aware of today, and then what should brands be most aware of that are looking to scale? So consumers, what should consumers be most aware of today?
(44:33) Dan: I—I have a—I don’t know if I coined it, but I have a line: the “better for you” category needs to be renamed to “better for a few.” Marketers ruin everything. The reason why plant-based milk blew up is because there’s a small subset of the United States population that has a lactose intolerance, about 5% of the US population. It sucks for them, they can’t eat cheese, they can’t drink milk, they can’t have dairy products. The companies behind oat milk, almond milk, originally soy, saw this as an opportunity of well if this is better for a few, it should be better for everyone, and they market it as if it is. So a product that has, you know, nine ingredients, shelf stabilizers, emulsifiers, is now healthier than a single ingredient item that comes from an animal, right? And so just be aware of that. Be aware that the industry is impacting you more than you believe. Marketers are impacting you more than you believe. The things they say you need, you don’t always need. And when you go back to kind of the tried and true things of like eat whole foods, optimize, take supplements to optimize your health, you don’t find yourself in all this noise of the latest and greatest trends. And especially in this age of social media, the quick clips, there is a like a visceral reaction to you see one thing, someone of notoriety says it, it then gets copied and republished and republished and republished and now it becomes the norm, right? So be aware of that. Just be mindful.
(46:17) Dan: A perfect example: how many people take melatonin? How many—now put your hands down—how many people think melatonin is bad for you? Why do you think melatonin is bad for you?
(46:33) Audience: Just not the best for you.
(46:37) Dan: So why isn’t it the best?
(46:39) Audience: Because there’s products that are actually better, like magnesium.
(46:42) Dan: Very—very good. And the reason I think it’s bad simply because if if something that my body’s supposed to produce on its own for me to have a natural thing like sleep, then I don’t want to take it and become addicted to it. That’s my psychology.
(46:56) Dan: So—so melatonin, a lot of people have this like kind of anti-melatonin attitude because of there’s been recent, you know, podcasts that have come out talking bad about it. I am going to make a hot take right now: melatonin will be the turnaround hormone ingredient of the year, and it’s based on a number of studies that have to do with free radicals. So there’s a misunderstanding of melatonin, how it’s produced. Majority of melatonin is actually produced in your gut, not by your pineal gland. And it is there’s a couple chemical reactions between tryptophan and serotonin, but in your gut it’s different. It is one of the most powerful free radical attackers in our entire body that we produce. And a lot of reasons why people say you need to get good sleep and you need to turn the lights down and you need to put your phone away is because that melatonin production is so important, but it also follows a different pathway than other hormone pathways, so taking exogenous melatonin doesn’t affect your natural production.
(48:02) Sebastian: It does not.
(48:03) Dan: No. And so this is I just use this as an example of like what we believe to be true based on information that we’re whether consciously or subconsciously taking in. But that is how marketing works. That is how, you know, people sell products. So just be aware, do due diligence, don’t follow the the herd.
(48:25) Sebastian: Yeah, I love that. Those are—those are great. Okay, next up was the other question: what should brands be more aware of that are trying to scale in the wellness industry?
(48:35) Dan: Do right by your customer because that will always do right by the brand. That’s like I mean it’s tried and true, it’s simple, but it’s and again, like classic stuff like chasing short-term results won’t, you know, create long-lasting results for your business. I would just say, yeah, the biggest thing is do right by the customer.
(48:58) Sebastian: I actually I lied, now I wanted to ask one more question, but I feel like community and IRL stuff, real-life stuff, is just blowing up because of what we experienced in the last few years. Do you see community building as a key thing for healthy?
(49:14) Dan: 100%. And we need to do better at it. We work with a lot of other like adjacent products, so in like athleisure companies we work with to try to but we need to do a better job of building up our community. And it is a real thing, you know, I think people will try the products because they either heard a recommendation from it, but they’ll continue taking the products because of the community you build around it.
(49:38) Sebastian: Got it. Got it. Awesome. Well, let’s give Dan a hand, please. Thank you, Dan. Thank you. And we’ll open it up to just two questions and then you all can connect with each other.
(49:54) Audience: I’m not loud enough already. Okay, good. Thanks for all the great info, this is all very useful first-hand information. Drop ship versus Amazon? Where are the economics of that and for a first-time CPG supplement person, what would you recommend?
(50:11) Dan: I—I have like a very visceral reaction when I hear dropship because basically it’s there’s no brand, right? You’re shipping something that’s already being produced for other people. Again, that kind of takes away the human element of it. I’ve never—I’ve never gone down that path, never been kind of a fan of it, in and and I’m sure there are some great businesses that do, you know, more than what we do in dropship and are successful. In the ingestible space specifically, again this is a place where I’m like you need to be working with legit manufacturers that, you know, have the customer in mind. So personally I’m not a fan of dropshipping. And what was the other question about Amazon?
(51:00) Audience: Yeah, I mean Amazon is like again, it’s like a love-hate thing. It’s the biggest marketplace in the world. You get exposure to a ton of customers, but again when I talk about like the lack of friction for your customer, me included, I’ll give you one example of Amazon. When I owned stores, we had two of our stores had OfficeMaxs literally right across the street in the shopping malls we were in. I was ordering office supplies on Amazon. I could have easily had one of our team members go across street and grab receipt paper, whatever we needed. And I didn’t because the convenience of me ordering for my five stores was easier than telling that two stores to go out and buy those products. That’s when it hit me of like that’s friction. The friction for me sending a team member to walk across the parking lot was more than me clicking on my phone, and I look at that from a customer standpoint. And you guys probably do it in your same in your day-to-day, like when you need something, it’s the convenience, wherever you’re at. If you happen to be in Target, you’re just going to grab it. If you’re not, if you don’t plan on going to Target, if there’s traffic, you’re just going to order on Amazon. So I love Amazon. Again, it’s like a love-hate thing, but I love it. I look at Amazon as a retailer, not as an extension of D2C, and that’s helped me out from a mindset standpoint.
(52:21) Audience: When building a CPG product or brand, how do you approach the customers that you want to sell to? So specifically for Dan where he was saying it kind of works well in a bubble with it being a higher priced product here LA is a bubble, kind of Miami, New York, all those cities. How do you approach selling to those customers while not completely disregarding middle America or just other subsets of groups?
(52:48) Dan: I—I think it’s specific to the brand, right? Like there’s plenty of brands that crush in Erewhon and they literally won’t do well anywhere else, right? And they’ve built a great business on the coast in and so there are products like that. I think it’s just dependent on where you want to take the brand. Do you want it to be a mass market brand or do you want it to be a super niche brand really, again, impacting high-income, you know, coastal areas? I think that’s a total kind of brand ethos and where you want to take it and what your kind of core values are. Like do you want to be accessible to everyone or is part of your brand strategy to be limited to be, you know, higher end, to be exclusive? So I think it really depends on the brand and where you want to take it.
(53:41) Audience: Hi, I’m Kodai. So I’m selling Japanese hair care in West Coast mainly. We’re selling in 50 locations now and Amazon, D2C. My question is, I see you know omni-channel, omni-channel is a key but I cannot measure like how is a retail success look like, you know, if I put the money on Meta, it’s, you know, it’s so hard to measure in, you know, retail. So I want to ask you like how you measure the retail success compared to, you know, D2C or Amazon.
(54:14) Sebastian: By the way, Dan, you gotta try Kodai’s shampoo and conditioner. It’ll leave that baby like silk, baby.
(44:20) Dan: All right, I’m going to give it a shot.
(54:23) Dan: You know, it’s funny, so think—thinking about pre, you know, pre-D2C, like that was how business was, right? TV commercials and you just kind of like sprayed and prayed, like hoped, hoped you’d get people through the doors. Like things haven’t changed that much. You know, if you if you want to, you know, do micro-targeting—and I’m not the expert in this space—but you know micro-targeting for those retailers, right? You’re going to you’re going to optimize your opportunity to reach customers in that kind of three-mile radius, right? I think it is a feedback loop with the retailer of you testing out different things. So if you’re testing out Meta ads, geolocating to a specific Target and then all of a sudden that retailer starts ordering more, anecdotally it’s working, right? And even if it’s not, your sales are increasing, right? Even if that’s not a direct correlation. So I think kind of just keeping, you know, just being aware of where your sales are coming from, where you’re spending to gain those sales. And if something isn’t working, then pivot, right? But yeah, there’s no, you know, again pre-Meta, pre-pixels on your website, like this was how marketing worked. And so yeah, it’s just kind of a but Amazon is a unique place where you can see if you start driving more traffic, you can see conversion rates, right? And I think if you’re able to drive traffic to Amazon and your conversion rates maintain, then you’re in a pretty good place and you could probably scale that into retailers. It’s, you know, it’s more of a leap of faith, but there is the anecdotal, you know, tracking of the of that spend. But yeah, it’s not it’s not easy.
(56:07) Audience: My question to you is: mentorship. Sounds like this came from your experience and your expertise came from a lot of tried and true error and things like that. Did you have somebody that mentored you throughout or at the beginning? Did you have somebody to throw ideas at that you can like that helped you through the process of—
(56:34) Dan: No.
(56:35) Audience: Okay. Would you suggest that somebody did?
(56:38) Dan: Again, my path I was my path. Yeah, if you can, you know, if you have resources that can cut out expensive mistakes, it can accelerate learnings. I think so. I think for a while there was like this real push that you need a mentor and you need to have someone by your side. And I don’t know if that screwed people up at all but of thinking like, well I can’t get started unless I have a mentor. I like to me that’s like, you know, that’s a problem. I think if you have an idea, you’re going to learn more by doing stuff and making mistakes on your own. But having someone that you can reference and you know kind of get feedback from, outside feedback is one of the most underrated things—whether it’s a mentor or a friend or you know someone that doesn’t have kind of any skin in the game in the business, I think is very valuable. And so yeah, whatever that is. I don’t I wouldn’t put a ton of weight on like before I start my business I need a mentor. I like I think that is I think that’s a problem because I do think there is value in screwing up. I think there’s value in in learning along the way. One of the big things we talked about this is like if you’re not embarrassed of your first iteration of your product, you didn’t move fast enough.
(58:02) Sebastian: Can you repeat that, Dan?
(58:04) Dan: If you’re not embarrassed by your first product—and I will I wish I should start bringing pictures of like what the brand looked like initially—you didn’t move fast enough. And the learnings that I have from our first launch in my stores to where we’re at now, it’s unbelievable. I don’t know if a mentor could have assisted in any of that. Again, I don’t I don’t think there’s a right or wrong way, but I wouldn’t put heavy emphasis on “before I move forward, before I make this decision, I need to consult my mentor.” Does that make sense?
(58:38) Audience: It does. And I was asking simply because it is more—I agree, I just mentor or not, you have to move forward. But sometimes you’re up against it. And it would be great to call somebody or ask them—how do you do that when you don’t know the person? Or you somebody’s like saying things that you’re like, “Oh my god, I’m up against that right now, great to reach out and ask.” Do you just go ahead and reach out and ask without them knowing?
(59:03) Dan: Yeah, or you know, put it into Claude, you know. I think there is just such value in learning and screwing up along the way. I don’t know. And again, maybe this is because I’m like bitter that I didn’t have a mentor. But like I can just picture like little things along the way—our first retailer sends me “All right, here’s your three portals. Get set up and and let us know when it’s done.” And I’m like, “What the like three portals? I got a shipping portal, I got a accounts receivable portal, and I have like a legal portal to run,” you know, like without having any idea of how to do anything. Yes, I could have reached out to someone who’s been in the space and done all this thing. But like figuring that stuff out, and then the next time it’s easier, and then the next time it’s easier. I don’t know. Maybe I do have a complex about not having a mentor.
(59:51) Sebastian: No, that was great. I appreciate it. Great question and great answer. Thanks again everyone, thank you for coming.
(59:59) Sebastian: Thank you guys.


